Log in

These US states see the lowest share of fatal crashes between September and November, with Florida ranking second safest for drivers

Posted

Summary

A five-year study found that Florida had the second-lowest share of fatal crashes during September, October and November, at 25.03%. North Dakota had the highest fall share at 30.63%.

Fall may not bring the same driving warnings as the middle of winter, but darker evenings, wet roads, fallen leaves and the first spells of frost can all make conditions more difficult.

A new study by motor vehicle accident lawyers Strype Injury Lawyers has revealed the US states where fatal crashes are least and most concentrated during fall.

Researchers analyzed fatal crash data for all 50 states between 2020 and 2024. They counted how many happened during September, October and November, then calculated the percentage this represented of each state’s overall fatal crash total.

The ranking is based on the share of fatal crashes occurring during fall rather than the raw number alone.

The 10 states with the lowest share of fatal crashes in fall

Rank

State

Total fatal crashes

Fall fatal crashes

Fall share

1

West Virginia

1,229

304

24.74%

2

Florida

15,959

3,995

25.03%

3

Hawaii

471

118

25.05%

4

Connecticut

1,478

383

25.91%

5

North Carolina

7,453

1,934

25.95%

6

Alabama

4,438

1,163

26.21%

7

Vermont

316

83

26.27%

8

New Mexico

1,996

525

26.30%

9

Texas

19,209

5,082

26.46%

10

Arizona

5,558

1,473

26.50%

West Virginia is the safest place for drivers this fall, accounting for the smallest share of fatal crashes. The state recorded 304 between September and November, representing 24.74% of its total of 1,229.

Florida has the second-lowest seasonal share at 25.03%, although its raw numbers tell a different story. There were 3,995 fall fatal crashes in the state, the third-highest total nationally, behind only California and Texas.

Only 0.02 percentage points separate Florida from Hawaii, which ranks third lowest. Hawaii recorded 118 fall fatal crashes from 471 overall, giving it a share of 25.05%.

Fourth lowest is Connecticut, where 383 of 1,478 fatal crashes took place from September through November. That works out at 25.91%, more than two and a half percentage points below nearby New York.

North Carolina ranks fifth lowest, with fall responsible for 25.95% of its fatal crashes. The state recorded 1,934 during those three months out of 7,453 altogether.

Next is Alabama. Its 1,163 fall fatal crashes made up 26.21% of the 4,438 recorded between 2020 and 2024.

Despite its northern climate, Vermont has the seventh-lowest share in the country. There were 83 fatal crashes during fall and 316 overall, producing a figure of 26.27%.

New Mexico places eighth lowest at 26.30%, based on 525 fall fatal crashes from a total of 1,996.

In ninth is Texas, where fall accounts for 26.46% of fatal crashes. However, the state recorded 5,082 fatal crashes during the season, the second-highest raw total in the country. Its position therefore means crashes were less concentrated in fall, not that its roads were among the safest overall.

Completing the bottom ten is Arizona. The state recorded 1,473 fall fatal crashes from 5,558 overall, giving it a seasonal share of 26.50%.

The 10 states with the highest share of fatal crashes in fall

Rank

State

Total fatal crashes

Fall fatal crashes

Fall share

1

North Dakota

457

140

30.63%

2

New Jersey

3,067

908

29.61%

3

Minnesota

2,033

596

29.32%

4

Wisconsin

2,749

801

29.14%

5

New Hampshire

580

168

28.97%

6

Idaho

1,089

315

28.93%

7

Illinois

5,671

1,640

28.92%

8

Nebraska

1,052

304

28.90%

9

Oklahoma

3,154

909

28.82%

10

New York

5,238

1,498

28.60%

At the top of the ranking is North Dakota, where 140 of the 457 fatal crashes recorded over the five years happened during fall. That gives the state a share of 30.63%, making it the only place in the country where the figure rises above 30%.

New Jersey ranks second with 908 fall fatal crashes out of 3,067 overall. Its share of 29.61% is just over one percentage point below North Dakota and higher than neighboring New York, Pennsylvania and Delaware.

Close behind is Minnesota. The state recorded 596 fatal crashes between September and November, equal to 29.32% of its five-year total of 2,033. It is also one of three Upper Midwest states to make the top 10.

Neighboring Wisconsin takes fourth place, with fall accounting for 29.14% of its fatal crashes. There were 801 during the season and 2,749 across the full period.

The top five is completed by New Hampshire. Of the state’s 580 fatal crashes, 168 happened during fall, producing a share of 28.97%. That is higher than the equivalent figures in nearby Maine, Vermont and Massachusetts.

Only a very small margin separates the next three states. Idaho places sixth at 28.93%, after recording 315 fall fatal crashes from a total of 1,089.

Just 0.01 percentage points behind is Illinois, where 1,640 of 5,671 fatal crashes happened during the three fall months. Its share stands at 28.92%, while its raw fall total is the highest of any state in the top 10.

Nebraska ranks eighth with 304 fall fatal crashes. These made up 28.90% of the 1,052 fatal crashes recorded in the state between 2020 and 2024.

In ninth is Oklahoma, where September through November accounted for 28.82% of fatal crashes. The state recorded 909 during fall and 3,154 across all seasons.

New York rounds out the top ten at 28.60%. Its 1,498 fall fatal crashes were the second-highest total within the top 10, behind Illinois.

That distinction can be seen clearly in California too. The state recorded the largest number of fall fatal crashes at 5,299, but these represented 27.18% of its total, placing it 32nd in the percentage ranking.

Commenting on the findings, Jeffrey Strype, Managing Partner at Strype Injury Lawyers, said: “Fall does not always get the same road-safety attention as winter, but conditions can still change quickly. Drivers may be dealing with darker evening commutes, rain, fallen leaves and early frost, sometimes within the same journey.

“North Dakota stands out because almost 31% of its fatal crashes happened between September and November. New Jersey and Minnesota are not far behind, while several other northern states also appear near the top.

“That does not necessarily mean these states have the most dangerous roads overall. The ranking looks at when fatal crashes happen during the year. California and Texas recorded far more fall fatal crashes in raw terms, but the season makes up a smaller proportion of their overall totals.

“The difference between the top and bottom of the table is not enormous either. Fall accounts for nearly one in three fatal crashes in North Dakota and around one in four in West Virginia, so this is clearly an important time of year for drivers everywhere.

“Before conditions begin to change, it is worth checking the car’s tires, lights, brakes and windshield wipers. Drivers should also leave more space in wet conditions and remember that fallen leaves can make the road slippery while also hiding potholes or road markings.

“It is also a good time to review your auto insurance. Check the coverage limits, deductible, roadside assistance and what support is available after a collision. If you are renting a vehicle or driving across state or national borders, make sure you know what is and is not covered before setting off.

“Insurance cannot prevent a crash, but suitable coverage can make the aftermath easier to manage. Finding out that a driver, vehicle or type of damage is not covered after an accident is something nobody wants to deal with.”

Key Points

  • Researchers analyzed fatal crash data from all 50 states between 2020 and 2024.
  • Florida ranked second-lowest, with 25.03% of fatal crashes occurring in fall.
  • North Dakota had the highest fall share at 30.63%.
  • California recorded the most fall fatal crashes, with 5,299.
  • Drivers are urged to check tires, brakes, lights and wipers and use extra caution on wet, leaf-covered roads.

Methodology:

Strype Injury Lawyers analyzed fatal motor vehicle crash data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System for 2020 through 2024.

Fall was defined as September, October and November. The number of fatal crashes during those months was divided by each state’s total fatal crashes across the five-year period and multiplied by 100.

A fatal crash is a motor vehicle traffic crash in which at least one person dies within 30 days. The figures count crashes rather than the total number of people killed.

Full ranking

Rank

State

Total fatal crashes

Fall fatal crashes

Fall share

1

North Dakota

457

140

30.63%

2

New Jersey

3,067

908

29.61%

3

Minnesota

2,033

596

29.32%

4

Wisconsin

2,749

801

29.14%

5

New Hampshire

580

168

28.97%

6

Idaho

1,089

315

28.93%

7

Illinois

5,671

1,640

28.92%

8

Nebraska

1,052

304

28.90%

9

Oklahoma

3,154

909

28.82%

10

New York

5,238

1,498

28.60%

11

Utah

1,351

386

28.57%

12

Montana

987

282

28.57%

13

Oregon

2,590

738

28.49%

14

Maine

751

213

28.36%

15

Nevada

1,798

509

28.31%

16

Wyoming

557

157

28.19%

17

Colorado

3,219

906

28.15%

18

Kansas

1,793

501

27.94%

19

Delaware

628

174

27.71%

20

Missouri

4,594

1,271

27.67%

21

Pennsylvania

5,498

1,519

27.63%

22

Mississippi

3,371

931

27.62%

23

Virginia

4,369

1,202

27.51%

24

Arkansas

2,894

796

27.51%

25

South Dakota

646

177

27.40%

26

Maryland

2,733

748

27.37%

27

Washington

3,253

890

27.36%

28

Kentucky

3,566

974

27.31%

29

Iowa

1,598

436

27.28%

30

Tennessee

5,874

1,599

27.22%

31

Indiana

4,222

1,148

27.19%

32

California

19,496

5,299

27.18%

33

Georgia

7,673

2,081

27.12%

34

Ohio

5,802

1,573

27.11%

35

Rhode Island

293

79

26.96%

36

Massachusetts

1,806

486

26.91%

37

Louisiana

3,960

1,065

26.89%

38

Alaska

310

83

26.77%

39

Michigan

5,173

1,384

26.75%

40

South Carolina

5,019

1,332

26.54%

41

Arizona

5,558

1,473

26.50%

42

Texas

19,209

5,082

26.46%

43

New Mexico

1,996

525

26.30%

44

Vermont

316

83

26.27%

45

Alabama

4,438

1,163

26.21%

46

North Carolina

7,453

1,934

25.95%

47

Connecticut

1,478

383

25.91%

48

Hawaii

471

118

25.05%

49

Florida

15,959

3,995

25.03%

50

West Virginia

1,229

304

24.74%

Florida fall traffic safety, fatal crash statistics, fall driving risks, seasonal traffic accidents, Florida car crashes, fall road safety

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here